Tuesday, March 28, 2017

Liberty Is for Human Thriving, not Just Convenience

This past week the United States Senate held confirmation hearings for Judge Neil Gorsuch. Hours of questions and answers provided a great opportunity to learn about how our government works.

One standout moment was when Senator Sasse (R-Nebraska) asked Gorsuch to teach a civics lesson on why we have the Bill of Rights. Gorsuch’s answer was brilliant -- what every American should know and always remember.

He first said, “The Constitution is a negative document.” We did not write a constitution to make sure the federal government had enough power, we wrote it to make sure that it never got too much power.

The theory behind the Constitution is to divide power. That protects liberty. America’s founders had learned the hard way that when “you put all power in one set of hands, you’re going to get tyranny.”

Let this sink in, deeply. The opposite of liberty is not inconvenience. The opposite of freedom is not a citizen who opposes your will, or who won’t do what you want them to. The opposite of liberty is government tyranny.

To stand up for liberty is not to argue for the right to have my way. It is to fight against the accumulation of power that can bankrupt your businesses, tear apart your families, and force your silence.

To protect this vital liberty America’s founders divided power in three ways. First, they divided the power of the federal government itself into three branches; Legislative, Executive, and Judicial. This is not just a convenient way of splitting up the work, as though there’s just too much for any one branch to do. This is a separation of powers.

It’s not merely that the legislature usually writes the laws, but sometimes it’s O.K. to have the other branches write laws too. Rather, if the judicial branch writes a law from the bench, they are not only taking freedom away from the person who is ruled against. They are taking a step toward putting both parties, and all the rest of us, under tyranny.

If legislators pass a law giving bureaucrats from the Executive branch authority to write the rules they will enforce, they are not merely speeding up the law-making process. They are selling their constituents out to tyranny.

So why do they do it? Because legislating is hard. It’s hard to get that many people to agree on something. That’s the point! Gorsuch reminded us, “It’s supposed to be tough, to protect liberty. We don’t’ just have one house. We have two houses.”

For something to become a law, it has to pass through both the 435 member House of Representatives, and the 100 member Senate. Then, it has to be signed by the president too! If you think this is too frustratingly slow of a process, and you want to speed it up by assigning the work to some committee, think again.

The people who wrote the Constitution had lost loved ones, and bled themselves. They learned the hard way that when it’s too easy to pass laws, too many laws are passed. And that’s very bad for human freedom. All of this is designed to be hard. Part of protecting liberty is making it difficult to legislate.

We, the people of America, are interviewing Gorsuch for a perpetual position on the highest court in the land. I can think of nothing that qualifies him better, than for him to answer, “The president’s powers are to execute the laws, not make them, not adjudicate disputes. Our role is to decide cases and controversies between people under law as it is, not as we wish it to be.”

Not only does he understand the purpose of three branches in the federal government. He knows that our Constitution divides power in another way as well. He said, “The federal government has certain enumerated powers and authorities. And what the Federal government doesn’t enjoy, the states do as sovereigns.”

The fact that state laws differ from state to state is not a problem. We do not need the federal government to impose lock-step uniformity from on high. The United States of America are states, first of all. They are united by a limited, federal government. The Constitution does not put limits on state powers, it put’s limits on federal powers.

It does this by enumerating what powers belong to the federal government. Then the Tenth Amendment states, “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” This is plain and simple language which means, if the Constitution doesn’t specifically say that Washington has the right to pass some law, they don’t.

This too is not just for convenience, but to protect us from tyranny. It allows the states individually to wrestle and experiment with all the difficult problems of forming a just society. This unleashes the ingenuity of the citizens in fifty different states to learn from each other and improve on each other.

More than that, it treats every citizen as a human being created to rise to the challenges of life by their own creativity, and not be hampered by the mistakes of others, far away. Federal overreach – whether it be a judiciary that throws out state’s marriage laws, or an executive agency that won’t let a man dig a stock tank on his own land – is an attack on our common humanity.

For this reason, America’s founders were still not through protecting our liberties. While many fine people thought that the Constitution was enough to prevent these tyrannies, others insisted that we needed still more protection. So, they added the Bill of Rights.

These ten amendments to the constitution picked out a few of the most basic rights and explicitly denied the Federal Government any power at all in these matters. Freedom of speech, press, and religion are among the first listed. So also gun rights, freedom from military or law-enforcement oppression, and the list goes on.

Those founders who were opposed to the Bill of Rights, were not opposed to any of the rights themselves. Everyone understood that these things should be protected without question. But there were those who feared that if we singled out any rights for protection, some federal bureaucrat would assume that they could mess with the ones we didn’t name.

So, perhaps the most important amendment of all in the Bill of Rights, is the Ninth Amendment. It says, “The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.”

This amendment takes us back to the main limiting function of the Constitution. All rights are granted, not by our government, but by our Creator. They are granted by the One who makes us human and gives us the responsibility to live as the human beings we are.

Tyranny, which does not recognize these rights, is not just an infringement against doing whatever we want. It is an attempt to replace our Creator, and, by extension, an attack on who we are, as His creatures.

Now, more than ever, we need to relearn the genius of the Constitution. Now, more than ever, we need to defend its original meaning. Now, more than ever, we need to elect those who will uphold it, and impeach those who do not. It shouldn’t matter whether that person agrees with our favorite policies or not. Because freedom lost, even for a good cause, is a loss for all humanity.

I’m glad that Judge Gorsuch gave us such an eloquent civics lesson. I hope that he is our next Supreme Court justice. But more than that, I hope that each and every reader of this column will dig deeply into the Constitution and stand with him in defending it.

Tuesday, March 21, 2017

Gun Rights Rooted in Responsibility to Defend


Last Wednesday (March 15, 2017) Governor Mead signed HB 194 “School Safety and Security” into law. That same day, he vetoed HB 137 “Repeal Gun Free Zones.” I applaud the first, but decry the veto.

This may come as a surprise to some. This pro-life, conservative, Christian is in favor of people carrying firearms into schools and into government meetings.

I have even encountered some cynics who attack my integrity. They claim that no one can honestly be pro-life while also defending the right to keep and carry weapons meant to kill a man.

Such inflammatory assertions usually pop up in Facebook memes. They are not invitations for rational dialog. But this challenge deserves a solid answer. So today let me outline a few points in reply.

First, we should dial back the rhetoric, just a tad. While I appreciate fine poetry as much as the next guy, a line from Lynerd Skynerd’s Saturday Night Special is hardly adequate to frame the debate about the Second Amendment.

“Ain’t good for nothin’ but to a put a man six feet in a hole,” does not adequately describe a concealable firearm. Hand guns are not built to kill people, but to defend them from being killed.

Designed so that their size and weight makes them easier to carry, they are more likely to be close at hand should the need arise. What kind of need? Let’s be clear. Law abiding carriers know that the only need for a firearm is when there is an imminent threat of grave bodily injury.

It is a tool of last resort to prevent grave bodily injury to yourself and others. Anybody who brandishes a weapon for any other reason is breaking the law and may be fined, jailed, or both. So, if that’s what you are worried about, relax. We already have strict laws on the books to prevent people from waving around pistols in public.

The problem is that someone who is intent on doing you grave bodily injury already is in contempt of the law and, so, is not likely to keep his own gun holstered until you threaten him. Nor is he likely to obey a state law which prohibits him from taking it into a public meeting. For those rare but real situations, the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees “the right of the people to keep and bear arms.”

Once we have dialed back the rhetoric, we are in a better position to consider this right. First, let’s consider the Constitution. Then, look at the principle behind it.

The first reason to advocate for the right to keep and bear arms is simply that this is the law of the land. We teach our children to follow the rules at school. As adults, we also follow city, state and federal laws. In the same way, we should expect and encourage our elected officials to follow the Constitution. This legal document sets boundaries on the kind of laws our elected officials can legally write, and legally enforce.

This is the rule of law, and it sure beats the chaos of tyranny. We are a constitutional government because we have seen the evils that arise when rulers have the power to say and do anything they think is right. If any elected official, or group of officials, is willing to ignore Constitutional boundaries in order to accomplish what they think is good, what principle will check their power?

C. S. Lewis wrote, “Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victim may be the most oppressive. It may be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron’s cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated, but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.”

At this point, someone might object and say that the 2nd Amendment was a bad idea. They may think it should be abolished, and that law-makers should have the ability to infringe upon the rights for persons to keep and carry arms.

Anybody is certainly free to think that. We even have a constitutional way to act on this thought and to amend the Constitution. But amending is lawful correction. Disregarding is lawless tyranny.

Imagine the chaos if the temperance movement had started fining and jailing people who made beer, without bothering to pass the 18th Amendment. Again, witness the corruption and murder that happened when lawmen who disagreed with the 18th Amendment disregarded it and illegally protected the mobs.

But while anybody is free to work at repealing the 2nd Amendment, I counsel caution. To do so would work against our basic humanity in a profound way.

All human beings are endowed by their creator with a deeply human impulse to help and protect those in danger. This impulse is not typically found among the higher animals. Soldiers, lawmen, EMTs, and firefighters will regularly run into harm’s way to aid the fallen. But, herds of deer and elk regularly run away from them.

When we, personally, see someone being bullied, we want to help them. We want to raise our own child to be the one that pushes through the crowd and stops the tormenter. As policy-makers, we want to find ways to provide effective tools that teachers and students can use to stop bullying whenever they see it.

We shame people who see one person abuse another and do nothing to stop it. In fact, we have laws which punish people who can do something about it, but don’t. That’s not only because it helps the person who is being abused. We can also see how dehumanizing it is to stand idly by without trying to help.

That’s the same principle involved in the 2nd Amendment. Rights are merely expressions of pre-existing responsibilities. The right to keep and bear arms was written into the Constitution because we each have a fundamental responsibility to help and protect our neighbor.

If I expect all my fellow citizens to stand up for a neighbor in danger of direct bodily harm, it becomes my own moral responsibility to equip him or her for the task. How dare I push somebody else into performing a dangerous and potentially deadly task while withholding the tools to do that task?

We all know how reprehensible it is for a government to send troops into the fight who are ill-equipped and at a disadvantage. The same goes when we want to cultivate a civilization where people help each other, no matter what the danger.

Much of the debate surrounding the 2nd Amendment is misdirected. We talk as though it were about personal rights and power. Things come into better focus when we consider our personal responsibilities to help and protect. Once we acknowledge these, our love and care for the protectors will make us desire to give them the tools they need.

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

Does the Neely Decision Maintain the Public's Faith in the Judiciary?



On March 7, 2017, the Wyoming Supreme Court handed down a 3-2 decision in the case of Judge Ruth Neely from Pinedale. Writing for the majority, Justice Kate Fox said, “Judge Neely violated Rules 1.2, 2.2, and 2.3 of the Wyoming Code of Judicial Conduct. However, we do not accept the Commission’s recommendation for removal, and instead order public censure, with specific conditions” (1).

Justice Keith Kautz wrote for the minority, “There is no clear and convincing evidence that Judge Neely violated any of the rules of the Wyoming Code of Judicial Conduct. Wyoming law does not require any judge or magistrate to perform any, particular marriage… There is no cause for discipline in this case… There is room enough in Wyoming for both sides to live according to their respective views of sex, marriage and religion” (56).

Before we look at the differences of opinion, we should note what they agree on.

For starters, the Court rejected every punishment recommended by the Commission on Judicial Conduct and Ethics (CJCE). They unanimously and unconditionally declined to remove her as municipal judge of Pinedale. They also agreed unanimously that she should not be removed as magistrate of the 9th Judicial District. Finally, they did not even consider the suggestion by the CJCE that she reimburse the state for prosecuting her.

As for the charges, the Court unanimously agreed that Judge Neely did not violate Rule 1.1 of the Code of Judicial Conduct. They further agreed that “Judge Neely remains ‘free to practice her [religious] beliefs,’ and she is ‘free to believe that marriage is a union between one man and one woman, as many Americans do” (17). Further, all five members of the court stipulate that a judge may openly “express her religious beliefs” (11).

Finally, the Court rejected the CJCE’s assertion that Judge Neely broke any rules merely by “announcing her position against marriage equality,” and that “judges do not enjoy the same freedom to proselytize their religious beliefs as the ordinary citizen” (Respondent’s Brief, 14,15). All of this is good news for anyone concerned about the erosion of First Amendment rights.

In spite of broad agreement, still the Court was sharply divided on the question of whether she violated the Code of Judicial Conduct at all. The majority says she did. The minority wrote, “I must respectfully, but vigorously, dissent” (33). The disagreement can be broken down into two basic topics: one being  Constitution, the other, the law.

The U.S. Constitution guarantees that “Congress shall make no law…prohibiting the free exercise” of religion. But the very first paragraph of the majority opinion posits a “distinction between the freedom to believe and freedom to act” (6). Then, throughout their discussion, they insist that this case is not about Neely’s beliefs, but about her actions.

It is awkward, however, that her “actions” consist entirely of words. She has never taken any action in a same-sex marriage. She has never been asked to. What she has been asked, first by a reporter and then by the commission, is to speak to hypothetical questions involving various scenarios. In the absence of any actual case, the Court is creating a verbal test that she must pass by speaking the right words.

It is especially the conditions required by the Court for her continuing in the magistracy that highlight the absurdity of this position. “She must either commit to performing marriages regardless of the couple’s sexual orientation, or cease performing all marriage ceremonies…” (32). But, when pressed by the dissent, they admit that judges can still turn down any request to perform any particular marriage ceremony.

This places the majority in the peculiar position of allowing a judge to decline to perform any marriage ceremony for any reason whatsoever--except one. Of course, such a stance remains non-enforceable so long as the reason remains only a thought. But it becomes punishable if it is spoken. How is this not the restriction of free speech?

One can approach it from the other side as well. The Court majority stipulates that she can speak freely about her religious views toward marriage. But, once she does, she is no longer free to exercise that religious view. So, the claim that “this case is not about same-sex marriage or the reasonableness of religious beliefs” (1) is true only as long as your words and actions contradict each other.

This ruling is predicated upon the Court’s assumption that the law requires each and every judge to perform same-sex marriages. This is what the majority means when they opine that a judge’s religious beliefs must not “interfere with her fair and impartial application of the law” (28). But is this assumption based in any legal text? Here, the dissenting opinion lays bare a glaring problem.

The Wyoming law that prohibits same-sex marriage (W.S. 20-1-101) was annulled by the 10th Circuit Court in 2014 (Guzzo v. Mead). But if the Wyoming Statute is no longer in effect, what law has replaced it? That’s the question that the majority opinion never really examines, but Kautz’ dissent does.

Guzzo v. Mead is a judicial decision (not a statute) which prohibits the state of Wyoming to “deny marriage to same sex couples or to deny recognition of otherwise valid same-sex marriages entered into elsewhere. Marriage licenses may not be denied on the basis that the applicants are a same-sex couple.” But Guzzo pointedly does not say who is required to perform these ceremonies. If it had, the CJCE would at least have a legal basis to say that Judge Neely refused to follow the law. But, as it is, this is an unwritten assumption.

Perhaps the Guzzo court wishes that they had stipulated this, or perhaps they intended to leave it to the state. All we know for sure is that they didn’t answer the question. But the majority opinion against Neely acts as though they did say what they did not actually say.

As a Lutheran pastor, I am one of these marriage performers under Wyoming law (W.S. 20-1-106). Does the majority opinion apply to me, or only to judges? They don’t say, just as the 10th Circuit Court refrained from saying. But if this Court is permitted to insert an unstated requirement upon judges into the Guzzo decision, what principle prevents some future Court from reading pastors, priests, and bishops into the same decision?

The truth is that the majority opinion has not interpreted the law, but written a new one. This is the most dangerous thing of all. This is particularly striking since the opinion was handed down at the close of Wyoming’s legislative session.

During the past 40 days, ninety legislators, dozens of lobbyists, and thousands of private citizens have engaged in a process of give-and-take. This process requires that bill pass nine separate votes. At each one of these votes, words can be added or subtracted, entire clauses can be rewritten, and unforeseen problems can be addressed.

All the while, citizens are advising their elected representatives and their elected representatives are working with one another to arrive at a law which will be clear, wise, and gain the greatest consensus possible. Then, even after all of this hard work, the bills face one more hurdle. It is Governor Mead’s burden to decide whether to sign, or to veto, two months and countless hours of work.

Contrast this with what just happened at the Supreme Court. In a hearing last summer, two people addressed the Court for only one hour. Since then, five people, worked in secret, with no public input for almost seven months. Finally, with a single 3-2 vote, they have added a law to Wyoming jurisprudence which can neither be amended where it is unclear, or augmented where it is insufficient. It cannot be vetoed by the Governor, nor taken up by the legislative process.

The majority opinion claims, from the outset, that this case is about “Maintaining the public’s faith in an independent and impartial judiciary that conducts its judicial functions according to the rule of law,” (1). This is certainly a noble goal. But for Judge Neely, to have a new law written by the very court that is judging her is an outrageous overreach. Faith in an impartial judiciary is only maintained by a judiciary that applies the law as written. Writing laws that favor one party to the dispute is the very definition of partiality.

Further Reading:
The Federalist: Wyoming Censures Judge for Marriage Beliefs Even Though No Law Requires Her to Perform Marriages
Wyoming Tribune Eagle: shorter version
Rock Springs Rocket-Miner: shorter version

Tuesday, March 7, 2017

Why We All Should Care about an Oregon Bakery

This past week (March 2, 2017), Aaron and Melissa Klein finally had their first day in court.

Here are the facts of the case. On January 17, 2013, a repeart customer of Sweet Cakes by Melissa, in Gresham, Oregon, entered the shop and asked the co-owner, Aaron Klein, to create a wedding cake for the occasion of her same sex wedding. Considering the biblical teaching on marriage (Genesis 2:24), he declined to create the requested cake.

At the time of the incident, the State of Oregon itself did not recognize same sex marriages. Nevertheless, in February 2013, civil enforcement officers from the state’s office of Attorney General, opened an investigation to see if Aaron had violated Oregon Equality Act passed in 2007.

Activists began to harass and threaten their suppliers into breaking business ties with Sweet Cakes. Physical damage was done to their delivery truck, and death threats were delivered to the Kleins. By September, they were forced to close the shop and work out of their home.

More than two years after the incident, in April 2015, an administrative court awarded $135,000 in damages to the customer. Then, in July of that year, the Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries (BOLI) made it final. The Kleins asked for a reduction of the amount since it would lead to their financial ruin. Brad Avakian, the Commissioner of BOLI denied their request.

They objected that they should not have to pay the penalty until their case was heard by a court of law. But weeks before Christmas, the state of Oregon emptied their bank accounts of nearly $7,000. Then, December 28, 2015, they were forced to pay an additional $136,927 to cover not only the penalty, but interest accrued.

In April 2016 they filed suit with the Oregon Court of Appeals. By September 2016, they announced that even the business that they had moved to their home was now closed down. Last week, on March 2, 2017, they finally had their first hearing before an actual court of law. The three judge panel heard their case but likely will not rule for several months.

These are the facts of the case, as neutrally as I can report them. Now it is time for some comments on its substance.

First, it is always troubling when the law is a moving target. At the time this case began, the State of Oregon itself did not recognize a same sex marriage as legitimate. The Oregon Equality Act had been on the books for five years and had never been used to prosecute the state’s own position. How, then, could anybody anticipate that an agency of the state, could penalize a citizen for its own position?

Since Hammurabi’s Code (1754 BC), one of the basic principles of law is that it is equally applied to citizen and king alike. In keeping with that, the law must be understandable and predictable. How are we to live equally under the law if nobody knows what the law says until some bureaucrat decides what it says?

Second, we should all be alarmed when judicial authority is usurped by the executive branch. Brad Avakian is the Commissioner of the Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industry, an executive agency. He, and the administrative courts of his agency have acted as judge, jury, and executioner from 2013 until now.

Within months of the initial investigation, Avakian declared that his goal was to “rehabilitate” the Kleins. A year later, their appeal for a more reasonable penalty had to go directly through him. A year after that, he authorized the seizing of their bank accounts – all before the judicial branch even heard the case. I don’t care where you stand on the right or wrong of the Klein’s case. Everybody should be alarmed at the power of a single bureaucrat to destroy a private citizen.

Third, justice delayed is justice denied. It would be bad enough if one government functionary had such discretionary power for even a month. But Brad Avakian has effectively controlled the finances of the Klein family for over four years. Even now that the case has finally been heard by an appeals court, it will be months before they have a chance to regain the money and assets that have been taken from them.

There is a reason that our courts treat people as innocent until proven guilty. To deprive people of money, property, and good name – even for a short while – has permanent consequences. Even should the matter finally be resolved in the Klein’s favor, they can never regain their business or undo the years of damage this has cost them.

Fourth, the Constitution was intended as a preventative, not as a last ditch correction. It is simply ludicrous that the words of the Constitution cannot even be considered until every bureaucrat has had his say. But that is what has happened here.

Aaron Klein explains, “Every time we tried to make a constitutional argument it was stomped on, because it was administrative law… But now we’re finally in a courtroom where the Constitution and due process can be argued on a level we haven’t seen before. I’m looking forward to seeing the outcome.” We see this same pattern happening in our own state with the prosecution of Judge Ruth Neely.

I recently reviewed the oral arguments of her case before the Commission on Judicial Conduct and Ethics (CJCE). Time and time again, when Neely’s defense attorneys would bring up statements in the Wyoming and U.S. Constitutions which should protect her from the actions of the CJCE, the attorney for the CJCE would blandly reply that such questions will have to wait for the Supreme Court to decide, “I don’t believe it is the prerogative of this panel or the full commission to decide and rule on constitutional issues.”

Fifth, justice involves proportionality. Even if you judge the Kleins to be in the wrong, consider the hugely disproportionate effects on the two parties. On the one side, a woman was upset by the treatment she received at the bakery, and verbal harassment from others when her case became public. She lost no money, was not physically assaulted, was not vandalized, or run out of business. On the other side, the Kleins have been vandalized, run out of business, treated as criminals by the state, and forced to give over $140,000 to an escrow account for the offended woman.

Would anybody call it just if a jay-walker were fined a year’s wages? Or, if pulling hair were punishable by death? I just watched a powerful movie called, Sophie Scholl: The Final Days. In it several college students were guillotined for passing out anti-government pamphlets. Disproportionality is the very definition of tyranny.

Sixth, and finally, the charge itself is obviously false. The person requesting the cake was a repeat customer. That means they had already proven they do not refuse service based on sexual orientation. It’s about what they were asked to say, not who they were dealing with. Is the creation of art free speech, or not?

Are cake-decorating, photography, and flower-arranging artistic performances protected by the First Amendment? Or can the government mandate what these artists must, or must not say? Be careful how you answer, or you too will soon be forced to dance to the government’s tune.

These are the questions raised by the case of an Oregon bakery. Although they are happening two states away, they hit very close to home. Every Wyomingite should care, because if Oregon prevails, we will all be served the same cake that Oregon is baking.

Tuesday, February 28, 2017

On the Passing of an Icon: Norma McCorvey

A week ago Saturday Norma McCorvey died at the age of 69. On February 25, she was laid to rest in Katy, Texas.

Norma is truly an icon of our time. If you don’t immediately recognize her name, you may know her better as Jane Roe, the plaintiff in the most far-reaching, and well-known court case in America. Roe v. Wade is a shibboleth of our time. For 44 years, it has been the dark star around which our world devolves.

The gravitational pull of Roe vs. Wade exerts its power on almost everything in our culture. The practice of medicine, the polarizing of a people, the definition of human personhood, the exercise of free speech, the concept of human rights, the natural bond between father and child, the legal protections for a child in the womb, and for her pregnant mother, the notion of privacy, tax policy, US foreign aid, and the entire trajectory of party politics… all of these have been stretched and distorted by a force-field centered on Norma McCorvey.

But here’s a curious fact found in her obituary: Her funeral was officiated by Father Frank Povone. Yes, the National Director of Priests for Life led the congregation in a funeral for Jane Roe. Hers is a tale that must be told.

As an icon of our times, Norma McCorvey is not a still photograph from 1973. She is a moving picture, the story of a life unfolding. We do a grave disservice to her, or anyone, if we judge their entire story from a momentary photograph.

Norma Nelson’s story begins in a troubled home. A violently alcoholic mother and sexual abuse by a relative led to reform school from the time she was 11. Her parents divorced when she was 13. She dropped out of High School at 15, ran away from home, and married Elwood McCorvey when she was 16.

That marriage dissolved while she was still pregnant with their first child, Melissa, who was signed over to her mother. A second child came by another father who raised the child without contact from Norma. Then, in 1969, a third child was conceived by yet another man.

Norma asked her doctor to put her in touch with an attorney to help her give the child up for adoption. Instead, he referred her to Sarah Weddington and Linda Coffee, two young lawyers looking for a vulnerable pregnant woman who would help them make history.

Her attorneys met with her three or four times. First, over a pitcher of beer, they convinced her to be the plaintiff in a case they were preparing. The last time, she signed an affidavit without reading it. It claimed that she had been gang raped and that she wanted an abortion. Both were lies.

That was the last time they ever met. They never helped her with an adoption. They didn’t offer her help for her drug and alcohol abuse, or help her get housing (she was living in a park). They had what they wanted: her signature on a piece of paper. It was their ticket to fame and the advancement of their cause.

It was March 17, 1970 and she was back on her own. That same year she gave birth to her third child and offered her up for adoption. That’s right. Norma McCorvey, the icon of abortion rights, never had an abortion. At the time she signed the affidavit, she didn’t even know exactly what it was.

Almost three years later, on January 22, 1973, she read the headlines about how Roe vs. Wade swept away nearly every state law concerning abortion. She had been unaware that her case ever went any farther after signing the affidavit.

Aside from the affidavit, there is no record at all in the case of Roe vs. Wade. There was no written discovery, no interrogatories, no document requests, no depositions, and no expert reports. Norma McCorvey never appeared in court. She was never notified of her case’s progress, or consulted for her wishes or strategic input.

Had she ever been asked a single question under oath, her case would have been dismissed before it ever got out of Dallas. But, as incredible as it may seem, her case percolated through the judicial machinery of Texas, District courts, Appeal Courts, and finally the Supreme court of the United States without either her participation or her knowledge.

At first she remained the anonymous Jane Roe. But soon she decided to cash in on her fame. By publicly identifying herself as Jane Roe, she became employable in any abortion clinic she wanted, and was the darling of pro-abortion rallies.

But her work in abortion clinics revealed to her what abortion actually was. After about a decade, she began to tell her story of being a pawn in the abortion-legalizing game. After two decades, she began to regret the legalization of abortion itself.

It was a little girl by the name of Emily who touched her heart with love and hope. Her mother worked next door to Norma’s abortion clinic. In 1995 Emily started visiting her regularly. It was her innocence, acceptance and love that broke through years of hurt and self-defense.

One day Norma accepted Emily’s invitation to come with her to church. Her experience of forgiveness was so powerful that her life took a 180 degree turn. Baptized by Rev. Flip Benton, the director of Operation Rescue, she left behind decades of abortion advocacy.

By 1997 she was received into the Roman Catholic church and spent the rest of her life trying to reverse the case that bore her name. On March 2, 2000, thirty years after she signed the unread affidavit prepared by Sarah Weddington, Norma filed an affidavit of her own. You should read it.

This affidavit was her opening statement in a legal battle to overturn Roe vs. Wade. After spending her final two decades speaking at pro-life rallies, testifying before the U.S. Senate, and trying unsuccessfully to correct the record, she now rests in peace.

Hers is a story that you should know. It encompasses much that is wrong with our culture. But it also encompasses much that can make it right again. It begins in a childhood that should not be wished upon anyone. It extends into a life out of control and searching for meaning. It ends in the hope of redemption and new meaning and peace.

Rest in peace, Norma. Your moving icon shows us all that redemption is never an empty hope.

See Also:
Wyoming Tribune Eagle: shortened version

Tuesday, February 21, 2017

Factual, but Fake: Untangling a Confusion

Recently, I was asked to take a survey from the Missouri School of Journalism. It was seeking to understand how people like me evaluated the credibility of news sources. But it never got around to asking how. It only asked what sources I trusted and where I fell in the political spectrum. If you want to know how, read on.

The President’s news conference last Thursday put the question in stark relief. In a particularly telling exchange with a reporter from CNN, the President said, “The leaks are absolutely real. The news is fake.” For some, this statement is utterly baffling, causing heads to explode. For others, it captures the problem in a perfect paradox.

To help my friends with exploding heads, let me offer a few reflections to reconcile the contradiction. Perhaps along the way we can understand one another better and find a more productive civil discourse. How is it possible that anyone can call a news story “fake” when the facts themselves are true? The answer can be summed up in four words: context, framing, balance, and comparison.

Let’s take them in reverse order. The first thing to remember in every conversation about politicians or public policy, is that judgments are comparative and not absolute. All politics is an attempt to strike a fair balance between any number of competing interests.

The U.S. Constitution was designed to put them in opposition to each other so that through public discussion we can come to a livable balance. States’ rights vs. Federal power, Executive branch vs. Judicial and Legislative, Church vs. State, and many others all meet in a glorious scrum of ideas.

Sadly, the evolution of the electronic media has increasingly undermined meaningful discussion. Neil Postman, in his brilliant book, Amusing Ourselves to Death, compares the depth of the Lincoln-Douglas Debates of the mid-19th century with the shallow thinking and short attention-spans of today’s interlocutors. It isn’t pretty.

While the print media at least possesses an inherent potential to be more thoughtful than cable news, this promise is largely dissipated. Instead of informing our sound-bite culture with a more nuanced analysis, they have themselves become bumper-sticker parodies of the evening news.

In a sound-bite culture, nuanced comparison is transmogrified into bombastic false dichotomies between absolute good and absolute evil. These, in turn, stir up powerful emotions that produce more heat than light. But they also produce money. Media moguls know how to exploit the emotions of their patrons to pad the bottom line. Worse still, politicians encourage these false dichotomies to stir up panicked support for their cause du jour.

Consider recent elections. Candidates bring up every possible unsavory detail of an opponent’s words and actions. Then they conclude with a rhetorical flourish like, “how could anybody possibly support that?” But, of course, no reasonable person does – not even those who pulled the lever for that candidate.

Voters do not – or, at least, should not -- support a person because of their character flaws, but in spite of them. Election is not a question of deciding who is good and who is evil. It is a matter of looking soberly at the good and evil of both candidates, or both policy proposals, and deciding which one, on balance, tips the scales more to one side or the other.

Balance is key. Not absolute loyalty. The election of people to office is neither the anointing of a savior, nor the destruction of a devil. It is weighing the strengths and weaknesses of any course of action and judging which is better and which worse. In a world where balance is key, it is necessary that all of the facts be placed in the scales, and not just some of them.

People stop listening to news outlets, not because they occasionally repeat a lie. These can be corrected. But a consistent pattern of refusing to report the facts of both sides leaves them hungry. Here is what mainstream journalism needs to understand and take to heart if they ever hope to fulfill their duty as the fourth estate.

Questions like that of the CNN reporter in Thursday’s press conference simply miss the point. Incessantly asking, “can you prove that I said anything wrong?” misses the more important question, “what necessary information have you left out of the story?”

Serious reflection on this question would go a long way toward helping mainstream journalism understand why conservatives are drawn to news sources outside of the mainstream. Thoughtful people are not looking for alternative facts. They are seeking the rest of the facts. If you want to keep them reading your papers and listening to your broadcasts, give them all the facts and not only half of them.

Balance is undermined not only by omitting certain facts, but also by omitting certain words. George Orwell put his finger on this phenomenon in his dystopian novel, 1984. There, “newspeak” was the mandated language of the pressroom. By expunging certain words from the dictionary and inventing others, Oceana not only created facts, they controlled the framework of thought, limiting the very thoughts that are possible.

While 1984 is fiction, it is far from fantasy. In our day, the mainstream media is the Ministry of Truth. Accordingly, the Associated Press keeps an ever-evolving dictionary of approved words and expressions and their corresponding forbidden words. Just look at two of the hot-button issues of our day.

According to the AP stylebook, the terms “pro-abortion” and “abortionist” are never to be used. The preferred terms are “abortion rights” and “abortion practitioner.” This word choice is clearly designed to cast one side in a more favorable light. But the same stylebook mandates that someone who calls themselves pro-life, must be referred to as “anti-abortion.”

We find similar framework bias in words about marriage. According to the GLAAD Media Reference Guide, both AP and Reuters stipulates that the term “sexual preference” is proscribed, along with “gay lifestyle.” These are always to be replaced by “sexual orientation.”

Obviously, GLAAD’s agenda is advanced by down-playing choices and behaviors. But for the AP and Reuters to adopt the word preferences of a special interest group into their official guide is biased journalism plain and simple.

Finally, weighing facts in the balance requires careful attention to context. If somebody has killed a man, it is important to know whether this was in the line of duty, or in a bar room brawl. The same goes for infractions against the incredibly complex rules of American government.

Take, for example, the case of Michael Flynn. It has been stipulated as fact that he contacted his Russian counterpart before being sworn in as National Security Advisor. This is against the rules. But it is also true that the Logan Act has been regularly violated for over two centuries. When reporting on the Flynn affair, failure to include this fact turns the entire story into fake news.

“You can fool all of the people some of the time, and some of the people all of the time. But you will never fool all of the people all of the time.” Whether or not honest Abe said these words, they contain a wisdom that cuts two ways.

On the one hand, it should be a comfort to everyone that the occasional false narrative will not long prevail. Whether it is misreporting by the New York Times, or by the Onion, some will believe it initially, but eventually the truth will prevail.

On the other hand, when vital information is consistently withheld in order to promote a progressive agenda over a conservative one, people will eventually come to distrust everything that comes from that news source, and seek another outlet altogether.

Such asymmetrical reporting is the greatest contributor to the polarization of the American people. By imposing one framework over another, and deliberately throwing off the balance, it sabotages civil discourse. The best thing we can do to prevent polarization is for every news outlet to strive for a full and fair reporting of every relevant detail.

This requires editors who actively seek out writings from all sides of the spectrum. It requires reporters who not only seek an occasional quote from the other side, but actually spend enough time with their ideological opposites that they can think within their framework and speak in their language.

We may not be able to change the culture on the pages of the New York Times, but each and every one of us can change the culture on our Facebook page. Remember, it is about comparison and balance, not absolute party loyalty. Admit weaknesses. Repudiate the inexcusable actions of your candidate. Seek to understand the framework and word-choice of the other side.

In so doing you will be joining the revolution and striking a blow for civil discourse. America can come together one civil conversation at a time.

Monday, February 13, 2017

True Freedom Is Common Ground

Last Thursday (2-9-17), the Senate Agriculture committee heard testimony for nearly four hours in consideration of two “social issue” bills. I drove to Cheyenne for the occasion, and what I saw and heard is worth noting.

The very fact that they were heard at all is a testament to the Senate President, Eli Bebout’s integrity. He found a way to schedule these important bills in the middle of an otherwise hectic legislative season. It seems I owe him a public apology. In hindsight, last week’s article on social issues was less charitable than it should have been. Thank you, President Bebout.

The committee first dealt with HB 116 “Abortion Amendments.” This bill seeks to amend Wyoming Statute 35-6-115 which says:
“Whoever sells, transfers, distributes or gives away any live or viable aborted child for any form of experimentation is guilty of a felony punishable by a fine of not less than ten thousand dollars and by imprisonment in the penitentiary for not less than one year nor more than fourteen years. Any person consenting, aiding or abetting such sale, transfer, distribution or other unlawful disposition of an aborted child is guilty of a felony punishable by a fine of not less than ten thousand dollars and by imprisonment in the penitentiary for not less than one year nor more than fourteen years or both, and shall also be subject to prosecution for violation of any other criminal statute.”


Let me emphasize, the above paragraph already exists in Wyoming law, and has for quite a while. Nothing in HB 116 suggested any new or increased fines, nor change in prison time, nor does it broaden the people to whom this may apply. In fact, it narrows the people who can be charged with this crime.

Currently, nobody at all is allowed to sell, transfer, distribute, or give away an aborted child. HB 116 adds exemptions which would give the child’s parents the right to do so. I’m not sure why anybody would oppose that change, but many did.

The only other change to the existing statute is that, where the current law applies to a “aborted child,” HB 116 would add the phrase, “or any tissue or cells from an aborted child.” When this Wyoming law was written decades ago, who could have imagined that body parts would be trafficked instead of an intact body. But such is the world we live in.

That’s it. There are only two changes suggested: one clarifying that if an aborted child cannot be experimented on whole, it shouldn’t be parted out either. Second, the granting of additional rights to the child’s parents. I naively thought that this bill would be simple to consider. It was not.

Rather, over the course of two and a half hours, many spoke for and against the existing statute, but few spoke to the two actual amendments. More than anything, the evening revealed how unsettled and sensitive is the subject of abortion. Forty-four years after the Supreme Court attempted to settle the abortion debate once and for all, we are no closer to unity now than we were in 1973.

Worse than that, there is pain. You could hear it in brittle voices, stifled tears, choked words. We need to find a path toward health and healing. The raw exercise of judicial power has not delivered what it promised. Let us come together in tenderness and love to care for those who have been broken. Mutual accusations are not the remedy. Understanding, forgiveness and care are.

For the next hour, the committee heard comments on HB 182 Abortion Ultrasound. This bill does not amend existing laws, but proposes a new one. It creates a new right for women. If HB 182 passes, every woman in the state of Wyoming would have the right to be informed by an abortion provider that she may see an active ultrasound if she so desires. Currently, this right does not exist.

But why should it be necessary for the government to make a law about it? This is a legitimate question and deserves a plain answer. After all, isn’t it already common practice among physicians to give every and all pertinent details before any medical procedure?

Before I could get a flu shot, I had to sign a paper that I was informed of my HIPAA rights, and before my two-year-old had work in his baby teeth, we were meticulously informed of the tiny chance that he could die.

Examples like those above could be multiplied ad infinitum. But, while it may be common practice in every other medical procedure, it is not in the case of abortion. Even where an ultrasound machine is used in the course of an abortion, standard operating procedure is to prevent the patient from seeing the screen.

It is argued that this is because of an agreement between an abortionist and his patient. But unless she is actually consulted about the decision, how can there be an agreement? In HB 182, if she is consulted, she can say so by a simple signature.

In order to check into my hotel room, I have to sign a piece of paper saying that I have been informed of the no-smoking and no-pets policy. Is a medical procedure less important than a night at the Super-8?

Yet, there are numerous documented cases where abortionists failed even to ask this basic question. Once or twice might be an oversight. But uncountable reports from women who were never given this basic medical courtesy, compels the government to step in and assure her rights.

Yes. I am in favor of granting women their rights -- all women, all their rights. If we are going to talk about the right to choose, we must also talk about the right to a fully informed choice – and not withhold pertinent information out of fear that she may not choose as I would. If we want to talk about the right to life, we must also talk about the right to have help and support in caring for that life.

I’m willing to have this conversation. Let’s work together to take away all ignorance and every coercion from women by taking responsibility as individuals and as a society. Let’s give women real choices and help them to take care of their children after they are born. Let’s get together and work together to support her in the long term.

First, let us strengthen her protections against rape. Then, let us strengthen laws which support marriage. Where these fail, let us let’s work together to take away this coercion. Let’s come together to learn what makes these women think they have no choice. Let’s come together to take away these fears and impossible circumstances and give her back her real choice.

Freedom is not just the ability to do what your fears forced you to do. Freedom is only free when fear and ignorance are chased away and you are free to live up to your highest ideals. That’s human flourishing.



See Also:
Wyoming Tribune Eagle: shortened version